Latest News

Russell: The UAE dumping OPEC will not have the same effect on crude oil as expected.

It is generally believed that the United Arab Emirates' decision to withdraw from OPEC will lessen the clout and influence of the producer group, as well as?start a race for increased production which could lead to a sharp drop in crude oil prices.

The U.S.-Israeli war on?Iran, however, has radically changed the global crude market to the point that predicting what would otherwise appear the most obvious result is probably flawed thinking.

The UAE may end up supplying more crude oil if the pre-war shipping volume through the Strait of Hormuz resumes.

These two outcomes may not be the only ones, nor as certain as they seem.

First, let's ask how much damage OPEC has suffered.

It is a big blow to lose the fourth largest producer. The UAE and Saudi Arabia, the de facto leader of OPEC, are two exporters that can ramp up production quickly.

The 65-year old producer group has survived departures in the past and managed to remain relevant and influence the global crude oil supply and price.

Angola left in 2024, Qatar 2020, Ecuador 2020 for the second, Indonesia 2016 and Gabon 1995. Gabon rejoined later. One could argue that none of these nations were as important as the?UAE. However, Angola and Qatar still count as major losers.

It would take a brave analyst to say that Saudi Arabia and OPEC+ members Russia are weakened by the loss of a Saudi Arabian member who?produced around 12% of OPEC output.

It will be interesting to see how Saudi Arabia and Russia react and if they decide to engage in a price and volume war.

This move is not intended to force the UAE into maintaining production discipline. This move would be more aimed at driving high-cost producers off the market. The primary target is U.S. shale production.

The irony of the situation is that while U.S. president Donald Trump welcomed the UAE's decision to leave OPEC it is the U.S. companies who will be the ones suffering if the move results in a price and volume war.

The Republican Party and Trump may benefit politically from lower retail fuel prices, but this outcome shows that Trump is not as friendly to his country's energy sector as he claims.

The impact may depend on the response to a re-opened strait

The main question about the UAE's move is whether it will lead to a price and volume war.

Before the U.S.-Israeli attacks on Iran, which took place on February 28, the UAE shipped about 3.3 millions barrels of oil per day. This effectively closed the Strait of Hormuz.

Analysts estimate that the UAE's production could rise quickly to 4.5 million?bpd, and reach 5.0 million bpd over the medium-term.

This assumes, of course, that the Strait of Hormuz will be fully and sustainably opened at some point. However, this is not certain given the current conflict and the apparent lack of progress among the warring parties.

Even if the Strait returns to its pre-war flow, will the additional barrels supplied by the UAE be enough to cause a significant correction in the price?

It is important to know what the 'importers' are doing, as well as what their tactics are.

Importers are attempting to replenish their depleted inventory as quickly as possible in anticipation of a new Middle East conflict. Or, do they adopt a more measured approach, hoping for a moderated price?

China is the world's largest crude importer. It has historically built up stockpiles during low-price periods and cut imports when they reach levels that its refiners deem too high.

China's massive stockpile of oil, estimated at 1.2 billion barrels, have not been used.

The U.S. will likely see its crude oil exports fall once the Strait of Hormuz has been fully opened, but it is not certain how quickly inventories will be rebuilt.

The question is also whether production in the Middle East can return to its pre-war level, considering that many fields and facilities have been damaged by drones or missiles.

The Iran conflict has created a large number of variables that make it difficult to predict how the UAE's withdrawal from OPEC would affect the group or the overall supply-demand balance.

You like this column? Open Interest (ROI) is your new essential source of global financial commentary. ROI provides data-driven, thought-provoking analysis on everything from soybeans to swap rates. The markets are changing faster than ever. ROI can help you keep up. Follow ROI on LinkedIn, X.

These are the views of the columnist, an author for.

(source: Reuters)