Latest News

Raychaudhuri: The South Korean stock market is cheaper because of the war in Iran, not weaker.

Raychaudhuri: The South Korean stock market is cheaper because of the war in Iran, not weaker.
Raychaudhuri: The South Korean stock market is cheaper because of the war in Iran, not weaker.

South Korea's stock market has become Asia's most volatile due to the Iran war. Fears of massive value destruction are probably unfounded, but the panic is real. The benchmark KOSPI index dropped over 18% in the two days following the start of the conflict on February 28. This was its worst ever daily drop. The next day, it recovered almost 10%. The market has been struggling with volatility for more than three weeks.

The 'KOSPI' is partly to blame for its own success. It had risen sharply in the year before the conflict began, and was up more than 100 percent over the previous year. Investors faced with uncertainty and the need for cash often sold their investments.

It is not surprising that the most liquid Korean shares in technology, chemicals, industrials and consumer discretionary stocks were the hardest hit. Conflict also weakened the outlook of some Korean companies, particularly after Iran closed the Strait of Hormuz. This narrow waterway was once used by roughly 20% of world energy to travel.

Korea International Trade Association shows that 70% of the crude oil and 30% of the gas Korea will receive in 2025 from the Middle East transited through the Strait. According to the International Energy Agency, Korea's energy mix is heavily skewed towards fossil fuels. 37% of its oil, 22% of coal, and 20% of natural gas are derived from Middle East.

On Tuesday, South Korean President Lee Jae Myung?called on a nationwide campaign to save energy. He asked the top 50 oil-consuming companies to reduce their use.

It is difficult to ignore the broad risk. A prolonged disruption in energy would increase the cost of inputs, fuel inflation, and squeeze margins for corporations. Since the start of the war, the Korean won has weakened sharply, adding to the pressure. This could trigger capital outflows.

Even with all the risks, some of the strengths that propelled Korean stocks before the war are still intact and may reappear in the minds of investors once the conflict is over.

Earnings boom endures

The outlook for earnings of Korean stocks remains positive despite wartime concerns.

Korea's consensus earnings per share (EPS) estimate has risen the most among the major Asian markets in the past year. These have risen despite the Middle East conflict. This shows that analysts are still bullish about the main drivers for profit growth despite concerns over energy shortages.

The majority of upgrades have been driven by the technology sector, primarily semiconductors. This is because the artificial intelligence revolution has not slowed down. Utility companies, energy and financial sectors have all made significant contributions, as well as?defence-exporters. The geopolitical conflicts should continue to be a support for the latter.

It is even more striking that, after a 40% rise in Korean stocks since late October, KOSPI's price-to earnings (P/E), based on FactSet estimates, has declined by 28%.

The forecasts for earnings-per-share have increased by 80% while the share price has lagged. This results in a market which looks cheaper based on future earnings, even after a good run. This dispels the myth that Korean stocks have become more costly since last year's rally. They haven't.

UNPACKING MISTAKES A second myth about Korean stocks that is often heard is that the market has become "crowded." Samsung Electronics, SK Hynix and other major players in the global market for memory did seem overbought up until the recent market selloff. However, the broader stock market tells a very different story. From November to March 25, foreign investors sold $36 billion in Korean stocks, with the sales starting long before the conflict. Since January 2020, foreigners sold $48 billion worth of Korean stocks, leaving them with a negative net asset value.

Thirdly, a third misconception is that investing in Korea means betting on the giant semiconductor companies.

Even though AI infrastructure hardware remains the clear leader, Korean prowess has also been well established in defence, shipbuilding and heavy engineering as well as automobiles, cosmetics retail, ecommerce, entertainment, and base metals. FactSet consensus predicts that most of these sectors will grow their earnings by over 20% in the next two-year period.

In many cases they are also attractively priced, with P/E multipliers that are significantly lower than the forecasted?earnings increase.

One caveat is in order. If war-related disruptions continue, energy-intensive sectors such as chemicals and heavy engineering could see their earnings decline.

GOVERNANCE & VOLATILITY The strong performance of Korea's equity market over the last year was also boosted by the corporate governance reforms, notably Seoul's Value Up programme, which aims to?boost shareholders rights. The government will need to reduce retail speculation to bring down volatility. While the progress made on this front is positive, it may be necessary to curtail corporate governance reform. Retail traders make up about a third of the daily turnover at Korea Exchange and use derivatives that are leveraged, which magnifies swings both ways. Regulators are taking steps to curb speculative trading and controversial practices such as illegal short-selling. The recent rise in technology stocks where leveraged positions were the most intense, however, indicates that more needs to be done.

The war's course is uncertain. A prolonged energy shock may have a negative impact on Korea's economy. When 'zooming in' on Korean equities current fundamentals, and foreign ownership's low exposure, there are plenty of reasons to believe that the war could be just a pause in Korea rally.

You like this column? Open Interest (ROI) is your new essential source of global financial commentary. Follow ROI on LinkedIn, X and X. Listen to the Morning Bid podcast daily on Apple, Spotify or the app. Subscribe to the Morning Bid podcast and hear journalists discussing the latest news in finance and markets seven days a weeks.

(source: Reuters)