Latest News

China's neighbors get the cold shoulder when it comes to energy.

China's neighbors get the cold shoulder when it comes to energy.
China's neighbors get the cold shoulder when it comes to energy.

Energy stress is spreading across Southeast Asia and governments are calling on China to fulfill its commitments for closer energy security by allowing the export of fuels and fertilisers, which were previously banned.

China, however, has only made vague statements. It has not publicly acknowledged the export bans reported by others. Instead it is focusing on protecting its own economy against the war in 'Iran.

Analysts do not expect this to change. They point out the tension between China’s declared ambition to become a more prominent player in regional affairs, and its realpolitik commitment to maintain its own economy ahead of global growth.

China is the second-largest fertiliser exporter in the world and also a major supplier of fuel. China's export bans have cut off a major supply source for many Asian countries, including Bangladesh, Philippines, and Australia.

Bangkok officials said that Dhaka had asked China earlier in the month to honor existing fuel contracts. Thai diplomats would then engage their Chinese counterparts so as to continue fertiliser shipments if necessary.

Officials in?Malaysia said last week that the Chinese export ban will worsen fertiliser shortages, especially in the oil palm industry. This is the second largest in the world. It's a blow to the war in Iran.

Even the Philippines has sought assistance despite disputes between the two countries over the South China Sea.

The Philippines Minister of Agriculture visited the Chinese embassy in Manila on March 17 and announced that China had agreed to continue fertiliser deliveries. Beijing's readout of a single sentence said that the two countries had only discussed agriculture.

On the same day, Australia, who imported a third its jet fuel last year from China, announced that it was in talks with Beijing about jet fuel exports.

Eric Olander is the co-founder and director of the China Global South Project. He said that China may provide some formal assistance but it would be highly unlikely if not improbable for China to share any substantial amount of food, energy or other resources with other countries.

Analysts said that Chinese policymakers likely quietly congratulated themselves for the strategic insight to start stockpiling weapons since?the early 2000s. This policy may have appeared excessive during peacetime, but it now appears surprisingly practical.

In an editorial published earlier this month, People's Daily, China's Communist Party's leading newspaper, praised China's relative security of energy and claimed that the country's forward-looking nature meant it held "the energy lifeline" in China's own hands.

China's Ministry of Foreign Affairs didn't immediately answer questions.

"A Tried and Tested Playbook"

China's Belt and Road initiative, which is the country's signature infrastructure project, has brought world leaders to Beijing regularly to discuss a 'win-win" cooperation. But with fuel and fertiliser in short supply across the region, Southeast Asian capitals have turned their attentions towards Russia.

"China will not want to create unrealistic expectations. Ruby Osman is a senior adviser at the Tony Blair Institute for Global Change and says that Beijing does not want to be a "regional energy backstop for a period of disruption indefinitely".

Beijing is likely to stick with its tried and tested playbook, which involves imposing broad, sharp curbs on exports of energy, energy-related products, before selectively restarting trade when officials are satisfied that the domestic demand will be met, said Ms. Liu.

China's political consciousness is still deeply rooted in famine and scarcity, and the trauma of Mao Zedong’s Great Leap Forward (GLF) and Cultural Revolution is still fresh enough to remember.

Max Zenglein is a senior economist with the Conference Board Asia. He said, "Only when China becomes more comfortable?with its exposure can I expect meaningful support." "I anticipate that any support provided will be transactional. Unfortunately, it's not a good situation to be in.

Wang Jin, senior fellow at the Beijing Club for International Dialogue (a think tank within China's Foreign Ministry), said Beijing would also benefit from the shock if it pushed trading partners to "accelerate investments in green and nuclear energies, sectors that China leads following years of state-backed investing.

Analysts said that China is under little pressure to act because no other major donors, such as Japan or a regional rival, are stepping up to help solve the shortages.

Olander compared it to the COVID-19 Pandemic when officials in the region looked at India as Asia's primary source of vaccines only to have New Delhi halt exports after infections soared in the country.

Osman says that China's partners who are seeking concessions should remind Beijing of their own commitments.

"Maybe it's best to just quote this new part of the five-year-plan back to Beijing. 'Strengthening international cooperation in food and energy, data and biological security, sea passage security and counter-terrorism, among other fields'."

(source: Reuters)