Latest News

Will US sanctions against Russian oil work? Russell

The crude oil market has a common belief that sanctions by the West against Russia's exports have little effect, as the market finds ways to keep the cargoes flowing.

It means that new measures will only have a temporary impact on prices. This is due to the fact that the flow of goods and services has been virtually unaffected.

It is possible that the same dynamics are at work with President Donald Trump’s latest sanctions announced last week against Russia’s two biggest oil companies, Lukoil, and Rosneft.

The two largest producers produce about 5% of all crude oil produced worldwide, or about 5.3 millions barrels per day. They export about 3.5million barrels a day.

After the new measures were announced on October 24, Brent futures rose as high as 8.9%, hitting a three-week trading high of $66.78 per barrel. In early Asian trading on Monday, it was unchanged at $66.37.

This may seem like a big price increase, but it is still well below the level that would have been reached if the crude oil market had believed that there was a real risk of losing as much as 3 million bpd to the seaborne markets.

Oil reached just below $140 per barrel when Russia invaded Ukraine, in February 2022. This was due to the fear of losing Russian exports.

It is expected that Russia's oil producers will be able circumvent new sanctions using a dark fleet of tanks and a variety of middlemen, and banking arrangements which avoid U.S. dollar.

This is the most likely scenario, as any disruption in Russia's crude oil exports would be limited and short-lived.

Does this mean the sanctions were a waste of time?

What you want to achieve is what matters most.

These latest measures will be ineffective if the goal is to stop Russian oil being exported by cutting of its remaining buyers, China and India.

Sanctions may be more effective if the goal is to reduce the revenues Moscow receives from selling its oil but keep Russian barrels on the global market.

New sanctions will make it more difficult for China and India to buy Russian oil. They are the two largest buyers of Russian oil.

It is likely that they will demand even steeper discounts to continue importing Russian barrels.

The cost of shipping Russian crude is also increased by using dark fleets and middlemen trading firms.

The cost of shutting out Russian oil companies from the U.S. banking system is also passed on to oil revenues, since money must be routed through shell companies and offshore jurisdictions.

DO SANCTIONS REALLY WORK?

Western sanctions against Russia have not had much of an impact in convincing President Vladimir Putin to stop his war in Ukraine. They are also unlikely result in a substantial reduction in export volume.

They make it difficult for Russia to export crude and the amount of money per barrel received may decrease.

This also means that the flow of Russian barrels is likely to change again as some buyers pull out.

Reliance Industries in India is a good example.

The company runs a 1,24 million bpd complex at Jamnagar on India's West Coast, which produces fuel for the domestic as well as export markets.

Reliance said that it would abide by Western Sanctions, meaning it could end its contract of 500,000 bpd with Rosneft.

According to commodity analysts Kpler, Reliance is also likely to buy some Russian crude at spot prices. Total imports of Russian crude oil through the Sikka port - which supplies Jamnagar - are expected to reach 591,000 barrels per day in October.

The average bpd was 766,000 in the second quarter. However, this is in line with 563,000 in the first.

Other buyers will have access to around 500,000 barrels per day of crude if Reliance stops its imports.

It is unclear whether India's government-controlled refiners are willing to accept the risk or if Chinese refiners can take on more Russian crude.

It will be important to see if Trump can reach trade agreements with India and China and if Russian oil is included in these deals.

Both New Delhi and Beijing are likely to want Washington to make significant concessions if they wish for their Russian oil imports be stopped or reduced significantly.

The Russian oil will likely continue to flow for now. However, the biggest risk to the market is if it is used as a tool to reshape global trade in the Trump era.

You like this column? Open Interest (ROI) is your new essential source of global financial commentary. ROI provides data-driven, thought-provoking analysis on everything from soybeans to swap rates. The markets are changing faster than ever. ROI can help you keep up. Follow ROI on LinkedIn, X.

These are the views of the columnist, who is also an author. (Editing by Himani Sakar)

(source: Reuters)