Latest News

Mike Dolan: The dangers of US oil-driven redistribution

U.S. indexes of the stock market have so far weathered the oil shock this month well because investors are expecting only a slight GDP impact from higher energy prices. This'resilience' masks the fact that income is shifting from households to 'Big Energy, and this could be a very dangerous trend in an election year.

As uncertainty continues to rage about the length and extent of the Iran War, the sharp and volatile rises in energy costs have caused oil and natural gas prices to look structurally higher for the coming year. Fertilizer shipments are also being held up in the Middle East Gulf region, which is causing concern about food costs.

The chances of a U.S. rate cut this year are reduced or delayed as inflation has risen again.

It's not good news for either the U.S. consumer or economy, until you consider that America is now a net energy exporter.

This is a huge windfall for the domestic producers and exporters who are supplying all of that oil and gas in the United States. There's also no threat to their security or any blockage of their product getting to market, unlike their competitors from the Middle East and elsewhere.

Carlyle's Jason Thomas, a strategist, points out that in the past 12 months the U.S. had an annualized energy surplus of almost $100 billion. The surge in oil prices is only going to increase this amount.

He wrote that "higher gasoline prices could still be thought of as a tax" on U.S. customers, but this is offset by an increase in revenues at home that did not exist in 2007-08 when the energy shock shaved more than 1% off the U.S. GDP.

The U.S. is now a net oil exporter for the first since the 1950s. Assumptions of a GDP drop of 2007-08 - one that could halve U.S. economic growth if the price of oil rose today by the same amount - are now out of date.

GLANCING BLOW

The "ready reckoner", a rule-of thumb guide created by Apollo Global Chief economist Torsten Slok, shows that even if crude oil remains above $100 per barrel until 2027 the shock will fade over time.

He showed that while the net effect on headline inflation can be as high at 0.7 percentage points, the effect on real Gdp, unemployment, and core inflation is only 0.1 percentage points.

The U.S. has been a net exporter of oil and its energy efficiency has increased significantly in recent years. This means that the economy consumes less oil for every unit of GDP than it did previously (and) this helps to dampen the negative impact of price increases.

Some people do not think it will be so easy if the shock continues.

Morgan Stanley estimates that, if an oil price jump of 25% caused by a supply shock lasted for four quarters, the real GDP would have been about 1.5% less, with the majority of the damage being in the first three.

The issue is, the GDP can still hold up quite well, even though it seems that everyone agrees that rising energy prices and inflation in general act as a tax to households.

PRESSURES FOR THE ELECTION YEAR

If a sustained oil crisis had the minimal impact on GDP that some claim, then the money from households already in a tight spot is simply being redistributed by the energy companies to the domestic market.

The government could step in and subsidizeand cushion household, but this would simply shift the burden to an already stretched Treasury.

Since the COVID-19 pandemic, the political toxicity of high U.S.?inflation headlines has been well documented.

Wall Street is convinced that the conflict in Washington will not be as severe and should therefore buy the dip, since GDP will continue to grow regardless.

A raid on the wallets of households that ends up in the coffers of domestic oil and gas companies might not go over well with voters, especially if they believe the oil'surge' was first triggered by U.S. armed forces.

The opinions expressed are those of the columnist, author. This column is a great read! Check out Open Interest, your new essential source for global financial commentary. Follow ROI on LinkedIn and X. Listen to the Morning Bid podcast daily on Apple, Spotify or the app. Subscribe to the Morning Bid podcast and hear journalists discussing the latest news in finance and markets seven days a weeks.

(source: Reuters)