Latest News

McGeever: Central banks will diverge from 2022 if the energy shock intensifies.

When the world was faced with a sudden surge in inflationary forces in 2021-22 due to a severe shock in supply and spikes in energy prices, all major central banks reacted?together. This is unlikely to happen again.

Five years ago, supply disruptions caused by pandemics led to a united - but belated cycle of interest rate hikes among the world's largest central banks. This cycle accelerated in response to the skyrocketing prices of energy triggered by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.

By the time the European Central Bank raised rates in July 2022 (and the Bank of Japan did not), every G10 central banks except the Bank of Japan had joined the party. All of them raised policy rates by 400-525 bps.

The war in the Middle East is causing the largest monthly increase in Brent crude oil price in history. It also disrupts other supply chains, which could lead to a rise in global inflation. This is causing central bank forecasts to be re-evaluated.

Rates are shifting accordingly. Many policymakers fear that they will be too late in responding to the inflationary threat.

The two U.S. rates cuts that were expected for this year have disappeared from the curve of futures. In addition, the ECB may now hike three times. And the reversal of the expected 'path' for UK interest rates is even more astounding.

Can we expect the central banks to move in lockstep like they did 5 years ago?

Not if supply becomes more scarce.

SCENARIO PLANNING

All rate markets are based on the assumption that the Middle East Conflict will soon end and the Strait of Hormuz reopens, allowing the global supply of oil, natural gas liquefied, fertilizer and other energy products, to flow again.

This benign base-case scenario assumes that energy prices will continue to rise after the war, but will remain high on an average annual basis. Global growth will also hold steady, which will justify a relatively hawkish position from most central bankers.

What if energy prices continue to rise, the war doesn't end, or the war doesn't end? What would the central banks do?

UBS economists estimate the effects of three Middle East conflict scenarios. These include a rapid resolution, a two-month disruption of the Strait of Hormuz with oil peaks near $130 per barrel and an "extended disrupt scenario" involving additional damage to energy infrastructure as well as oil reaching $150.

They believe that in the event of a recession that is caused by the Federal Reserve, it could reduce U.S. interest rates to zero next year and that the Swiss National Bank will again use negative interest rates.

Bank of England could reverse only two or three of the rate increases currently expected for this year. The ECB may not reduce rates at all.

UBS economists noted that "considerable differences" exist between economies.

No one knows about POWELL

The U.S. labour market stagnates today, but the average monthly job increase in 2022 will be over 600,000. In comparison to five years ago, the current price pressures, tariffs and all, are relatively benign. Policy is also much tighter. Will the new Fed chair rush to raise rates in an economy that is weakening?

The euro zone labor market is tighter today than the U.S., while growth is near trend and monetary policies are more neutral. Moreover, since the ECB has only one mandate, which is to achieve a 2% inflation rate, it's more likely that they will tighten policy than ease.

You can imagine a scenario in which the central banks diverge. This could increase volatility, widen interest rates and bond yields, accelerate currency swings and cause macro volatility. There is already a lot of uncertainty in the markets.

Jerome Powell, Fed chair, said at his press conference after his March meeting that no one knows the economic effects of "the war" - not even him or his colleagues. It's therefore impossible to determine the best policy at this time.

We can expect that, the more the central banks are impacted by the disruptions, the more likely they will act independently.

You like this column? Open Interest (ROI) is your new essential source of global financial commentary. Follow ROI on LinkedIn and X.

Listen to the Morning Bid podcast daily on Apple, Spotify or the app. Subscribe to the Morning Bid podcast and hear journalists discussing the latest news in finance and markets seven days a weeks.

(source: Reuters)