Latest News

Russell: Crude oil futures prices are a measure of market adaptability and not a sign of Iran peace.

Since the beginning of the Iran War, there has been a debate about whether crude oil futures accurately reflect?the stress in the physical markets for oil and refined products or if the are blindly 'optimistic' that peace is on the horizon.

The Iran War between the United States of America and Iran continues on its volatile and unpredictable course, with renewed hope that there is a chance for a new pause in the?reverse strikes.

This flicker of optimism led Brent futures to fall in the early Asian trading on Monday. The price fell by nearly 5%, reaching around $92.06.

The Strait of Hormuz is still at best contested. Shipping volumes have dropped through the narrow waterway after surging in mid-June during a three-week ceasefire between the Trump Administration and Tehran.

After the collapse of the deal and the renewed U.S. attacks on Iran, Tehran responded with a series of strikes against U.S. bases and vessels attempting to cross the Strait of Hormuz.

Tehran appears to also have activated its Houthi ally in Yemen to target Saudi oil tankers that are trying to cross the Bab el-Mandeb Strait.

This eliminates a route that Saudi oil could have taken to reach refineries on the Asian continent via the Red Sea Port of?Yanbu. Alternative routes include a much longer and more complex route via the Suez Canal. This involves partial discharging of cargoes as well as using the SUMED Pipeline due to draft restrictions.

Overall,?the crude oil exports out of the Middle East are still constrained. There is a limited volume through the Bab el-Mandeb and Hormuz straits.

A lasting peace agreement also seems distant as the United States is far from Iran on important points, and they are deeply distrustful of each other.

UKRAINE LESSON

This situation seems to call for a much stronger reaction than what has been seen in the oil futures market.

Brent fell as low as $70.14?a barrel during the brief cessation of hostilities on July 2. It then rallied by 45%, reaching a high price of $102.00 in July 23 before falling back.

This may seem like a big rally, but it is still well below the $139.13 peak Brent achieved in the weeks following the Russian invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. At the time, this event raised concerns about the disruption of Russia's exports, as they were the second largest crude shipper.

These fears were not justified, as crude markets quickly adapted. They rerouted Russian oil to China and India buyers while Europe increased its imports from Americas and Africa.

The situation is different with the?Iran conflict in that there is a real disruption of crude supplies. And the longer this continues, the more the buffers are strained by inventory drawdowns as well as China's reduction of imports.

The argument is that crude futures are not high enough to reflect the risk of a prolonged disruption in Middle East crude supply, which appears to be more likely.

It's less likely that crude futures will not price the worst-case scenarios, or even the best-case scenarios of "lasting peace", and more likely they will price adaptability.

The market has effectively bet that it will handle disruptions through rerouting of flows and increasing alternative sources.

The Suez Canal is a more expensive and longer route for Saudi Arabian Red Sea crude to reach Asia, but this is still possible and will be done if the market demands it.

Other smaller workarounds, like Iraq sending fuel oil to Turkey are also emerging. These, when combined, help reduce the loss of approximately 10 million barrels of crude and products per day from the Middle East.

It may be that the market is betting on traders of crude and refined products to help mitigate the worst effects of the Iran Crisis.

You like this column? Check out Open Interest, your new essential source of global financial commentary. ROI provides data-driven, thought-provoking analysis on everything from soybeans to swap rates. The markets are changing faster than ever. ROI can help you keep up. Follow ROI on LinkedIn, X.

These are the views of the columnist, an author for.

(source: Reuters)