Latest News

EU promotes temporary energy subsidies but costs could balloon

The European Union will propose targeted measures to 'avoid further strains on fragile public finances' when it outlines looser rules for state aid next week.

Nine European finance officials and economists warned, however, that the combination of voter pressure and right-wing populist gains, coupled with fuel duty reductions and price caps, could lead to a ballooning in state aid costs and fiscal costs as long as the war continues.

The European economies are facing a third shock in six months, following the COVID epidemic and an energy crisis caused by Russia's invasion. The governments of France, Italy and Spain are also under pressure to protect consumers from price increases, as elections will be held in France, Finland, Greece, Slovakia, Finland, Greece, and Spain next year.

Alfred Kammer, head of the European Department at the International Monetary Fund, said that after the pandemic and Russian gas crisis, people expect the government to act whenever a crises occurs.

He said, "This crisis is external and affects everyone on the planet. But there are still bailout expectations."

According to the Jacques Delors Energy Centre 22 of the EU 27 countries have 'already implemented protective measures that cost more than 10 billion euro ($11.7 billion). These include VAT and excise taxes reductions, delayed increases and price cap.

According to the think tank Bruegel, these measures - which include 3.5 billion euro in energy VAT reductions in Spain and a 1.6 billion euro energy tax reduction in Germany – rely largely untargeted tax cuts on fuel.

"Despite what some governments claim, these measures 'are not really temporary. They are likely to stay in place until the crises is over which could take a long period of time. "Some of the COVID temporary measures are still in effect," a senior euro zone official stated.

According to the International Energy Agency, the conflict is the biggest energy crisis that the world has ever seen. According to the European Commission, disruptions in Middle East oil and natural gas supplies have added 24 billion euro to the EU's total fossil fuel import bill during the first 50 day of the conflict.

KNEE JERK REACTIONS Vs STRUCTURAL RESFORMS

The Commission proposed on Wednesday changes to the electricity tax, coordination of summer gas refilling and possible obligations to?states for holding jet fuel stocks.

Avoid impulsive, costly reactions that may provide a short-term fix but do not deliver structural changes necessary to buffer future energy price shocks.

It is planned to relax state aid rules next week, retroactively to March, and for a period of time up to the end 2026. This will allow governments to subventionise fuel prices and fertilisers in the most affected sectors, such as farming, fishing, and road transport.

Analysts?warn governments that they will be unable to withdraw their support if war continues.

Dan Jorgensen is the EU Energy Commissioner, and former Danish energy minister. He said: "I understand national circumstances and pressures will lead you to make decisions that you wouldn't normally make."

He said: "We understand and will help facilitate in certain instances. But we must insist that this is very targeted, and temporary."

Oil prices will remain high even if the conflict is resolved soon and the Strait of Hormuz opens again.

The fiscal cost of these emergency measures quickly adds to large amounts, said Elisabetta Cornago an analyst with the Centre for European Reform.

Phuc Vinh Nguyen of the Jacques Delors Energy Centre urged EU-wide actions to reduce energy consumption to ease pressure on supply and prices.

"We are facing more fiscal and budgetary restrictions .... Nguyen stated that public finances will not be sustainable in the long-term.

(source: Reuters)