Latest News

McGeever: It's time to reconsider the asset of a "safe haven"

The Iran War and the 'global energy shock' it unleashed could have put an end to the idea that there is a safe-haven investment for everyone.

It's not a novel concept given the poor performance of U.S. Treasuries after Russia invaded Ukraine in 2004. The extraordinary fall in gold prices'since the U.S. and Israeli strike on Iran on 28 February' has brought it into the spotlight.

In times of economic, geopolitical or financial instability, investors flock to assets like Treasuries. The dollar, Swiss Franc and especially gold. These are the assets that will most likely serve as a safe haven in times of crisis.

Gold has been a safe haven for non-financial assets, especially in times of inflation. Gold has not only performed poorly in the current crisis, but it is also one of the most underperforming assets.

It has lag behind high-yielding credit, emerging markets stocks, and frontier market stocks. Silver was the only asset that has performed better than it, and this is because of a speculative boom.

Gold has fallen 17% in March so far, and is on course to have its worst month since 1982. This is astonishing in a month marked by the worst Middle East conflict, biggest global energy crisis, accelerating inflation, and $6 trillion worth of global stock value being wiped out.

Around the middle of 2012, gold began to be untethered by whatever economic fundamentals were underlying it. Retail investors, momentum traders, and machines chased gold higher as central bank demand cooled. It culminated in a January high of $5 595 per ounce. This "fear of losing out" (FOMO), euphoria soon turned into widespread liquidation and drowned out any "FTQ", or flight to quality, demand sparked by this crisis.

PLENTY OF REASONS TO SELL, FEW TO BUY

The dollar and U.S. Treasuries are not much better.

The dollar has risen but only by less than 2 percent. The Federal Reserve is not the only major central bank that will likely tighten its policy this year.

Analysts at Deutsche Bank note that many central banks from Asia and the Middle East will likely look to reduce their FX reserves to cover their increased import costs, to prevent their currencies weakening excessively, and to cushion any inflation shock.

This will cap dollar and could be a greater drag on U.S. Treasuries. This may have already begun. The amount of Treasuries that are held by the New York Fed for global central banks fell by around $75 billion over the past four weeks.

Analysts at Deutsche Bank estimate that this is equivalent to around $60 billion in sales by the official foreign sector. This would be the second-largest net sale since the COVID-19 Pandemic. It's true that the Treasuries Market is the most liquid market in the world. But it is no longer considered the safest.

The Swiss franc, and the Japanese yen are both affected by domestic problems. Both currencies have historically enjoyed current-account deficits and low rates of inflation.

The Swiss National Bank has stated that it is more willing to intervene on the foreign exchange markets due to currency appreciation. The yen is already at multi-decade lows and doesn't hold much appeal, given that Japan imports most of its energy.

Investors need to be flexible and more creative in the current turmoil. Trading strategies are often more effective than buying safe-haven assets. The response to each crisis depends on its origin, for example, buying energy stocks during an energy crisis, or buying defense stocks during a conflict.

Cash is the one asset that seems to always do well during a crisis or even an inflationary supply shock. U.S. Money Market Funds have grown by about $60 billion since the 28th of February to a record $7.86 trillion. You shouldn't bet against the total exceeding $8 trillion within weeks.

You like this column? Check out Open Interest, your new essential source for global financial commentary. Follow ROI on LinkedIn and X.

Listen to the Morning Bid podcast daily on Apple, Spotify or the app. Subscribe to the Morning Bid podcast and hear journalists discussing the latest news in finance and markets seven days a weeks.

(source: Reuters)