Latest News

Chinese coal buyers reject new Indonesia price benchmark

Chinese coal buyers reject new Indonesia price benchmark

Indonesia's efforts to introduce a price set by the government for coal are not making any headway in China, its top customer. This undermines Jakarta's attempts to gain more control over its commodity exports.

On March 1, Indonesia started using the HBA, a new price set by the government that was previously only used to calculate royalties. This is to give Indonesia more control over both the domestic and export value of the fuel commodity.

Despite the fact that it has been almost two months since the HBA was introduced, two Chinese coal traders claim the majority of Chinese buyers still use the old Indonesian Coal Index. The new benchmark, according to traders, is less transparent and updated less often. It is also more expensive.

Most exporters are not using the ICI price, according to the Indonesian Coal Mining Association. This is partly because buyers have a better understanding of the ICI pricing system.

"We conducted an evaluation and are currently reviewing the impact." We will then present the results of the assessment to the policy-making leadership.

Julian Julian refused to reveal details of the assessment of the Ministry and didn't comment on the low take-up rate of the HBA benchmark.

Indonesia, the top thermal coal exporter in the world, struggles to influence pricing for its coal exports, valued at $17.2 billion in China last year, according to China’s customs data. This highlights the challenges Indonesia faces to assert its role on global commodity markets, as it strives to reform its mining sector and boost domestic processing.

According to the Ministry of Finance, the new benchmark is intended to be used for spot trades starting in March. Exporters are expected to honor long-term contracts that have been priced using the ICI standard.

Josua Paradede, Chief Economist at Permata Bank said that the new pricing policy aimed to increase revenues for coal exporters as well as the government. He said that the strategy might "backfire" in case higher prices push buyers to other sources.

A coal company in Indonesia, who asked to remain anonymous, said that high HBA costs made the switch difficult. The company still uses ICI sales.

Toby Hassall is the lead coal analyst for LSEG. He said that many Indonesian producers already operate at a loss. This policy could deter investors from investing in Indonesia's mines.

WEAK DEMAND IN CHINA HITS PRICES

Su Huipeng is an analyst with the China Coal Transportation and Distribution Association.

Customs data shows that China's imports of coal were down by 6% on an annual basis in March, to 38.73 millions metric tons, due to a weaker demand at home and lower prices. Indonesian shipments also fell, with a further 9% decline.

In March, China Shenhua Energy, a major importer of coal, stopped all purchases due to the increasing port stocks.

Analysts predict that China's coal exports will fall in this year's comparison to 2024. This will further reduce Indonesia's leverage.

CCTD forecasts that China's thermal imports – which accounted for virtually all Indonesian coal shipments to China in the past year – will drop by 5%. Analysts at Guosheng Securities also predict a decline. Reporting by Colleen Hogue in Beijing and Bernadette C. Christina and Fransiska Naangoy in Jakarta. Editing by Tom Hogue.

(source: Reuters)