Latest News

Republican lawmakers are faced with a clean-energy dilemma as they work on a tax bill

Republican lawmakers are faced with a clean-energy dilemma as they work on a tax bill

Republican lawmakers who are working to extend President Donald Trump’s tax cut legislation face a clean-energy dilemma at home. Major clean energy investments are being made in their districts, but Trump’s skepticism about the industry is at odds.

The Ways & Means committee of the House of Representatives, which is responsible for drafting the tax legislation to extend the 2017 tax cuts, has 11 Republicans who represent regions that have seen green energy investments of hundreds of millions or billions of dollars over the past few years.

Clean energy investments boomed after former President Joe Biden's Inflation Reduction Act passed a then-Democratic-controlled Congress in 2022, authorizing hundreds of billions of dollars of clean energy tax credits for businesses, most of which were not capped.

According to the data collected by Atlas Public Policy and Utah State University, since then, companies have invested more than $165 Billion in clean energy manufacturing across the country.

The House Republicans want to reduce federal spending by at least $1.5 trillion dollars over the next decade. This is to offset the cost of extending tax cuts, which will likely be more than $4.5 billion.

The data shows that more than 75% -- or almost $125 billion dollars -- of clean-energy investment was targeted to Republican-held congressional district.

Trump had long called electric cars a hoax, before he forged a close alliance with Tesla. He also claimed to have bought one at an event held by the White House last month.

In his district, east of Memphis in Tennessee, Representative David Kustoff touts Ford's investment to build a new production hub for the electric F-series pick-ups, which was boosted by legislation.

Ford and its South Korean partner SK Innovation contributed the majority of the $6.5 billion invested in the district over the last four years. This is the highest amount of any House Republican tax writers.

Kustoff, speaking to the Jackson Rotary Club about the tax writing process, said that it was important for the people of west Tennessee.

Two people familiar with this pledge say that the White House tried to convince fiscal hawks in the House who were working on the budget to move the chamber forward, in a document released in February, to eliminate the green energy tax credit "to the maximum extent possible" to generate new revenue and offset any new costs that could be incurred in the tax bill.

Ford works behind the scenes with legislators to maintain tax credits, according a source familiar with the discussions.

Balance of Party Line versus District

Honda and General Motors, the two other automakers with the most investments in clean energy, invested billions each into electric vehicle battery factories for the districts that followed.

Representative Mike Carey praised the estimated 2,000 manufacturing jobs that Honda will create in South Bend, Indiana, in his district, southeast of Columbus, Ohio. Representative Rudy Yakym, in a press release, said he was "thrilled" about GM's historic investment in 2023, which included 1,700 jobs in South Bend.

In the district of Representative Beth Van Duyne, a tax writer and representative from Fort Worth in Texas, a new rare-earth magnet production facility was built.

MP Materials has invested $700 million into the facility to achieve its goal of becoming "America's First Fully-Integrated Rare Earth Magnet Manufacturing Facility". In a press release from 2024, they said that the Biden-era 2022 law funded a tax credit for energy projects worth almost $60 million.

Kustoff, Carey Yakym and Van Duyne declined to comment on their tax priorities.

A GM spokesperson stated that the tax credits for advanced manufacturing production "advance U.S. Leadership in Critical Technologies" and have led to the automaker announcing thousands of new jobs in three states.

According to data, Republican legislators represent 16 of the 20 top House districts in the country with the most recent investments in clean energy manufacturing. Last month, many of them spoke out against "disruptive" changes to the nation's energy taxes.

Ryan Bernstein is the leader of McGuireWoods Consulting's energy practice. "You won't be able to see much dialogue in the public eye, so it will create a dark box on what will or won't be included."

Josh Brown, President of the Tennessee Chamber of Commerce said, "It's very important for the government to honor its commitments when companies make decisions that are dependent on federal or state actions." He cited Ford's huge investment in rural western Tennessee. "Any chance that this investment might be curtailed or withdrawn based upon congressional action is extremely concerning." (Reporting and editing by Scott Malone, Alistair Bell and Scott Malone; Additional reporting by Kalea in Detroit)

(source: Reuters)