Latest News

Andy Home: Beer, not tariffs will boost US aluminum capacity

If in doubt, double down.

Seven years ago, President Donald Trump imposed 10% tariffs on U.S. aluminium imports with the stated goal of increasing domestic primary metals production.

They haven't worked.

The tariff will be 25 % this time, with no "exceptions or exclusions", effective on March 4. The tariff will be 25% without "exceptions or exemptions" effective March 4.

The sharp rise in the price for aluminum delivered to the U.S. Midwest is bad news for U.S. customers.

The effectiveness of higher tariffs in revitalizing the country's aged fleet of aluminum smelters is also uncertain.

The humble beer can is a great way to achieve greater self-sufficiency in aluminium.

Import Dependency

Aluminium and steel have been lumped together again in Trump's tariff battles, despite the fact that they are very different markets.

According to the U.S. Geological Survey, while U.S. imports of steel account for only 23%, aluminium accounts for 47%.

The U.S. relies heavily on the importation of primary aluminum from Canada. Canada supplies over two million tons each year.

Markets are already adapting to possible shifts in trade flows and pricing.

In a matter of a few days, the CME Midwest U.S. Premium contract, which captures delivered metal costs on top of the underlying aluminum price, grew by $100, to $629 per metric tonne.

The implied tariff cost has not been fully priced because the London Metal Exchange is currently trading for $2,645 a ton.

Tariffs for 2018 on the aluminium market were highly negotiable. Canada was included at first, then excluded, included again, and exempted once again. This happened twice in a single month.

It seems that the same carve-outs will occur this time.

The European premiums for Canadian metal have fallen sharply. This is a sign that Canadian shipments are being diverted away from the American market, which has higher tariffs.

Tariffs for POWER TRUMPS

Aluminium production has not been affected by steel tariffs.

From 20 at the beginning of the century, the number of primary aluminum smelters in the United States has decreased to four.

New Madrid, Missouri, the only plant that reopened after tariffs in 2018 closed in January 2024.

The U.S. primary steel production in 2018 was 670,000 tonnes, compared to 740,000 tons the previous year, before import tariffs first came into effect.

The "Green Aluminum Smelter Project" of Century Aluminum, which was awarded $500 million by the Department of Energy under the Bilateral Infrastructure Act and Inflation reduction Act of the previous administration, is the only hope.

Century just drew down the first tranche of $10 million to fund future studies. This tells you that a new smelter will not be starting up anytime soon.

The project is still in need of a source of renewable energy that will allow it to be classified as green.

Electrolysis is the process that produces aluminium, and it consumes a lot of energy to turn alumina into a metal.

High power costs are the main reason for the demise of U.S. Smelters. They remain the biggest obstacle to any greenfield smelter projects.

Data centres are increasingly competing for renewable energy.

Don't Litter

It is easier for the United States than ever to reduce its import dependence.

It is easy to find the solution, but it is often thrown out.

With 106,7 billion aluminium cans sold in 2021 (over a quarter of global consumption), the country is the largest consumer of aluminum beverage cans.

According to the Container Recycling Institute, recycling rates were only 43% in 2023. This is down from 57% in 2014.

Under half of cans are thrown out to be landfilled or trashed. The improper sorting of metal at recycling plants results in a loss of about one-third.

CRI estimates that the total waste in 2021 will be over 1 million tons of aluminum with a nominal value of $1.6 Billion.

This is a significant amount of aluminum that's wasted every year, and it's more than the domestic production of primary metallic. Remelting an aluminum beverage can uses a fraction of the energy required to produce virgin metal.

All countries with high recycling rates have some sort of deposit return system.

According to the CRI, states that have deposit schemes in place achieved a rate of recycling of 74% compared to 26% for states without deposit schemes.

If you introduce more deposit return schemes, some of the one million tonnes landfill waste could be returned back to the supply chain.

The energy shortages in the United States mean that increasing recycling will be a more effective way to increase its domestic aluminum supply than tariffs.

Tariffs will be imposed on the aluminum market and the U.S. consumers.

These are the opinions of the columnist, an author for.

(source: Reuters)