Latest News

Europe's response to the energy crisis avoids consumption limits for now

The energy shock caused by the Iran War is causing countries around the world to look for ways to conserve fuel. This could be through encouraging remote work, limiting air travel or promoting public transportation.

In Europe, however, this is not the case.

The impact on Europe is not as bad as it was in 2022 when Russia invaded Ukraine and cut off gas supplies. This led to record high prices and fear of shortages.

The cost of living, energy and other factors are also used as political battlefields. This is a region that saw protests by the "yellow jackets" in France in 2018 over an increase in diesel taxes and in the UK where politicians on the right have called local programs to reduce emissions "anti-car crusades".

Analysts say that governments would rather spend money to protect households from the rising cost of fuel than to encourage or require them to reduce their energy consumption.

Phuc Vinh Nguyen is the head of Paris' Jacques Delors Energy Centre. She said that demand-reduction policies are not popular by nature, and therefore, policymakers may not want to devote too much political clout in promoting them.

Nguyen, the director of the centre, said that fewer than 10 policy measures, which are mostly voluntary, were aimed at reducing energy consumption. The EU's recommendations to governments, published last week, omitted several measures to reduce consumption. These included organising "car-free" days and encouraging companies to implement more remote work. The European Commission did not respond immediately to a question about the change.

The European governments have committed a total of nearly 14 billion euro ($16.38billion) in response to the energy crisis. This is a fraction compared to the 500 billion euros that they had offered back when the year 2022 was first announced, but it still puts pressure on the already stretched public budgets.

In addition, there has been a focus on blanket measures, such as the fuel-tax reductions seen in Germany, Spain and Poland, instead of focusing support on vulnerable households.

"GENTLE SUGGESTIONS" TO AVOID PANIC

Some say that such steps not only cost more but also reduce the impact of the energy transition shock by making electric vehicles and heating systems cheaper than fossil fuels.

Ilian Mihov is a professor of France's INSEAD Business School. He noted that the oil price shock in the 1970s prompted automakers to improve fuel efficiency.

Guidelines from the EU and International Energy Agency to reduce energy consumption in 2022, when gas prices reached record levels, included home-working at a reduced speed and reducing driving. Britain launched a campaign to show people how they can save energy and stay warm in the winter.

However, with European gas prices below the levels of 2022 and with no fuel shortages to date, governments in Asia are being more cautious than those countries that are more dependent on Middle Eastern oil.

Poland's Energy minister Milosz Motyka warned this month that "hard measures and restrictions can lead to panic" and could cause a supply disruption.

He said, "We're making suggestions in a gentle way and we hope that drivers will adapt to this new situation."

This approach speaks to the fact that some Europeans are hesitant to be told to conserve energy, rather than do it themselves. It also highlights the importance of well-crafted messages which resonate with people.

Before the current energy crisis, French drivers accepted the idea of driving more slowly to save fuel. Nguyen noted that enforced lower speeds have not been popular. Toby Harris, the chair of Britain's National Preparedness Commission (an independent advisory body), said that unless the public understands the magnitude of the issues we face, it will be difficult to convince them to reduce their fuel consumption.

This does not mean that Europeans are against energy conservation.

According to the IEA, a 2022 campaign aimed at curbing energy use in Ireland was linked with a 12% drop in electricity consumption in homes. One poll revealed that 90% of Germans consciously saved heating energy in the winter after Russia invaded Ukraine.

Some people say that even though governments may claim the shock isn't severe enough to curb energy consumption, it's still a good idea to do it anyway because it will lower prices and help to fill gas storage over the summer.

Michael Bloss, German Green MEP said: "In a scarcity situation, this is how you reduce the price - by reducing demand." "And the majority of policies we see are actually increasing demand."

Enrico Giovannini said that restrictions on working and travelling also have an economic cost. They should be used only as a last option.

He added that if the war continues, "more drastic measures will be taken."

(source: Reuters)