Latest News

Investors are worried that Big Oil may reduce its share buybacks if crude prices fall

Investors are worried that Big Oil may reduce its share buybacks if crude prices fall

Investors will pay attention to how the falling oil price has increased the risk of dividends and share purchases for the remainder of 2025.

Big Oil's efforts to win over Wall Street have been based on returning cash to investors via dividends and stock repurchases. U.S. president Donald Trump's announcements of global tariffs have caused fears of a weaker oil market and a possible recession, leading forecasters to reduce their oil price expectations.

If prices were lower, Big Oil would have less money to give to its shareholders.

In a research note, Paul Cheng, a Scotiabank analyst, wrote: "We believe the quarterly results will get overshadowed given the turmoil on the commodity markets."

Analysts said that investors will be looking for companies that can describe their plans to deal with the sustained decline in oil prices. This could include reducing share repurchases or cutting back on spending.

Exxon, and Chevron are the two biggest oil producers in the United States. Both companies will report their earnings on Friday, and they're expected to show a profit increase from the previous quarter. According to LSEG, analysts expect Exxon to earn $1.73 per share and Chevron $2.18.

Brent crude oil prices, the global benchmark, averaged $74,98 per barrel in the quarter January-March. This was an increase of 1.3% over the previous quarter. U.S. natural gas prices rose 30%.

After Trump announced tariffs against trading partners, oil prices started to plummet on April 2.

Analysts have been modeling scenarios in which oil prices will remain around $60 this year, or even fall into the $50s.

Brent oil prices averaged $66.79 per barrel so far in April. The U.S. Energy Information Administration cut its price forecast from $74.22 a barrel on average to $67.87 per barrel in 2025. The EIA expects a price average of $61.48 per barrel in 2026. This is down from the previous $68.47.

Analysts from four companies have said that Chevron could reduce its buybacks in the event of continued low oil prices. Analysts from four firms said that the second-largest U.S. energy company had previously set annual share repurchases at between $10 billion to $20 billion.

The company has announced that it will be cutting costs by up to $3 billion and firing up to 8,000 workers.

Analysts said that BP in the UK may also be forced to reduce its share buybacks, increasing pressure on already-underperforming shares.

RBC Capital Markets estimates that Chevron needs a Brent price per barrel of $95 to cover dividends, buybacks, and other costs. Exxon requires $88. Prices in the mid-$50s can cover dividends for both companies.

Bank of America Global Research analysts forecast that Chevron would repurchase about $11 billion worth of shares in this year. This is at the lower end of their guidance. Exxon will buy back around $13.5 billion below its $20 billion guidance.

At least three analysts agreed that Exxon was in a better position to continue dividends and share purchases, citing the surplus cash on its balance sheet and the company's efforts to reduce the cost of producing oil and natural gas. Exxon said that it would repurchase shares worth $20 billion annually until 2026. Last year, the company paid out $16.7 billion as dividends.

Exxon-Chevron has not responded to any requests for comments.

Jason Gabelman is an analyst with TD Cowen. In a note dated April 11, he wrote that it was unlikely the companies would announce a reduction in capital expenditures in the near future, but this could happen in future quarters.

He wrote that spending on green energy projects and shale assets would be the most suitable for cutting. Shale production is more flexible and can be stopped and restarted quickly, while energy conversion efforts are still not material to businesses. Chevron will spend 65% of its 2025 capex on these two segments, while Exxon will spend less than 50%. Sheila Dang, Houston; David Gregorio, editing.

(source: Reuters)