Latest News

US appeals court voids $16.1 billion judgment against Argentina over YPF seizure

US appeals court voids $16.1 billion judgment against Argentina over YPF seizure
US appeals court voids $16.1 billion judgment against Argentina over YPF seizure

The U.S. Court of Appeals on Friday ruled against Argentina's $16.1 billion judgment for seizing the?state-owned oil firm YPF in 2012. This is a major victory for Argentine president Javier Milei as he tries stabilize Argentinean economy.

The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan issued the decision. Circuit Court of Appeals of Manhattan. Argentina was seeking to reverse the $16.1 billion award made in September 2023 to former YPF investors Petersen Energia Inversora, and Eton Park Capital Management by a lower-court judge for alleged losses related to YPF’s nationalization. During the oral arguments of October 29, the three judge?appeals panel questioned the reason why the case is in the United States when the underlying activity took place?in Argentina, and involved alleged Argentine laws.

Burford Capital is a UK company that finances the litigation. Burford Capital will collect 'a large portion of any award which survives legal challenges. When the appeal was heard, the award had grown from $18 billion to include interest.

Following the decision of the appeals court, shares of Burford dropped by more than 15 percent in U.S. stock trading.

The appeal was about Argentina's 'decision' to expropriate 51% YPF shares from Spain Repsol without making a bid to Petersen or Eton Park, YPFs second and third largest investors.

YPF was a private company since 1993. Cristina Fernandez de Kirchner was Argentina's President in 2012. She said that YPF needed to be renationalized as it did not produce enough natural gas and oil to meet the local demand.

ARGENTINA SAID A LARGE AWARD COULD Cripple the economy

In September 2023 U.S. district judge Loretta Preska of Manhattan found Argentina in breach of its obligations towards Petersen?and Eton Park and ordered it to pay them $14,39 billion and $1,71 billion respectively.

These sums included $8.43 billion in?damages plus $7.67 million of prejudgment interests at an 8% interest rate.

Argentina maintains that a large award could cripple the economy. It has struggled with high inflation and debt for years.

According to the country, this $16.1 billion payment represents 45% of Argentina's budget for 2024.

Petersen and Eton Park's lawyer defended the decision to pursue the case in United States, stating that Argentina's economic struggles as well as its "penchant for nationalism" could mean investors are not treated 'fairly' by the country's court system.

Argentina also appealed Preska's order of June 2025 that it hand over the YPF share to partially satisfy the $16.1 Billion judgment. The 2nd Circuit has rescinded that order. Reporting by Jonathan Stempel, New York; editing by Rod Nickel

(source: Reuters)