Latest News

Google's battle over Android Auto access is lost as EU court supports Italian watchdog

Google's battle over Android Auto access is lost as EU court supports Italian watchdog

The refusal of Alphabet's Google to let an emobility app created by Enel to access its Android Auto platform could be deemed an abuse of market power, Europe’s top court ruled on Tuesday. It sided with Italy’s antitrust authority.

The Italian watchdog fined Google in 2021 102 million Euros ($106.7 Million) for blocking Enel’s JuicePass, a software that lets drivers navigate using maps on the dashboards of their cars and send messages.

Google had refused to allow JuicePass to be compatible with Android Auto citing security concerns. The Italian Council of State then sought advice from the Luxembourg-based Court of Justice of the European Union.

Google has resolved the issue but the ruling could be used to guide future dominant companies in similar situations.

The CJEU judges supported the Italian regulator.

They said that "a refusal by a company in a dominant position, to ensure its platform is compatible with the app of another firm, which becomes more attractive thereby, can be abusive."

The Court said that companies could justify their refusal in the event there was no template for the app category concerned. It also stated that granting interoperability would compromise security or integrity of a platform.

If that's not the case, it said the dominant company would have to develop a model within a reasonable time frame.

The decision is final and can't be appealed. Google's appeal will be decided by the Italian Council of State in accordance with CJEU ruling.

C-233/23 Alphabet & Others

(source: Reuters)