Latest News

Vanguard's fund board votes are dominated by anti-ESG concerns

Vanguard's fund board votes are dominated by anti-ESG concerns

The Republican U.S. State Treasurers are withholding their votes from Vanguard's nominees for fund boards, due to concerns that the slate lacks "tone" in sustainability issues. This presents a major political obstacle for the top mutual funds manager who is trying to increase turnout at a rare trustee election scheduled for Wednesday.

The officials are responsible for a tiny fraction of Vanguard’s assets, which total $10.1 trillion. They're unlikely to affect the outcome of the vote that will elect Vanguard CEO Salim RAMJI and the 13 fund trustees.

Their objections to several prominent directors shows the difficult political calculus faced by asset managers who are under attack by Republican politicians, even as they drop priorities that were once considered mainstream.

Vanguard has, for example, rolled back its boardroom diversity guidelines, promised to take a less hands-on role with banks and left a zero-effort.

Vanguard representatives didn't respond to any questions.

Eight state finance officials, led by Missourian Vivek Malak, wrote a letter on February 24 to the Pennsylvania company, which was seen by. They called Vanguard's slate of products "tone deaf" to recent legal and legislative pushback, as well as regulatory pushback, against consideration of environmental and social factors.

Malek, in an interview, gave the example of Sarah Bloom Raskin. She is a director and former Fed official who was unable to be nominated for a high-ranking Federal Reserve position because her climate risk concerns were too great.

Malek also cited David Thomas as a strong advocate for diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives. Thomas is a director at Vanguard since 2021, and president of Morehouse College in Georgia. Vanguard's proxy says Thomas's "research on diversity management and published works are nationally renowned."

Malek stated that the examples show the board is lacking in ideological balance despite recent changes to the firm's policies. Malek stated that he thought Vanguard's management should be heading in a new direction.

Malek manages an educational savings portfolio of $4.5 billion, with 90% invested at Vanguard. Glenn Hegar of Texas, who has $1.86 billion in Vanguard, as well as Pennsylvania Treasurer Stacy Garrity with $6.2 billion, were also signatories.

Raskin and Thomas didn't immediately respond to our questions.

Jeff DeMaso who edits a Vanguard newsletter said that the criticism shows just how difficult it is for investment managers to talk directly with portfolio companies or the public about ESG issues.

He said, "Right now there's a certain element of trying to determine what the rules are."

Vanguard funds are divided into 35 trusts that are overseen by the exact same trustees. For quorum to be achieved, a trust's net assets must equal a third.

Vanguard still sought participation as of February 19, according to an SEC filing. Vanguard urged clients to vote, saying that "every vote counts". This would allow Vanguard to avoid the extra costs and time of proxy solicitation. (Reporting and editing by Lincoln Feast; Reporting by Ross Kerber)

(source: Reuters)