Latest News

Brazil's environment minister and climate summit star faces political struggles at home

Brazilian Environment Minister Marina Silva fought tears while global diplomats applauded for several minutes Saturday at the closing plenary session of the COP30 climate summit.

She told the delegates in the Amazon rainforest town of Belem that "we've made modest progress, even if it was modest." Then she raised her fist defiantly above her head. "The courage to face the climate crisis is a result of persistence and collective efforts." The Brazilian hosts were able to release their frustrations in the tense room where many nations expressed their displeasure with a deal which failed to mention fossil-fuels, even though they praised more funding for developing countries adapting to climate changes.

Despite its bittersweet result, COP30 was the culmination of years of hard work by President Luiz inacio Lula and the Environment Minister to restore Brazil's global leadership on climate policy that had been weakened by a predecessor from the far right who denied climate science. In Brasilia a more harsh political reality is looming. Congress has been trying to eliminate much of Brazil's environmental permits system. The Amazon has a large organized crime problem. People who want to clear forests have also found ways to infiltrate groups that promote sustainable development.

All of this presents new threats to Brazil’s vast ecosystems. Lula and the minister he appointed are forced to fight a back-up battle to protect the largest rainforest in the world.

Scientists and experts in policy warn that urgent action is required to stop deforestation, before climate change turns the Amazon rainforest into a hotbed. The tensions between the conservative Congress and Lula, a leftist, have been rising ahead of next year’s general elections. Forest land is at greater risk during election seasons.

Silva is still adamant that Brazil can achieve its goal of reducing deforestation by zero by 2030.

She said, "I must survive if I am in the eye of a storm."

MIXED RECORD

Many at the COP30 thought Silva was more of a rock star than a policymaker. She was born in 1958 to slum rubber tappers in Acre, Amazonia. She, too, overcame poverty and a lack of education to gain global recognition. She slowed down the destruction of her native forest as his environment minister between 2003 and 2008. Silva, who had been estranged from Lula's Workers Party for more than a decade, reunited in 2022. Many environmentalists believe that her return is the most significant move in Lula's current term on climate policy. He has cast his agenda, as an "ecological transform" of Brazil's economic.

This is in stark contrast to the deforestation that occurred under Jair Bolsonaro's predecessor, who was a right-winger and favored mining and ranching within the rainforest.

Juliano Assuncao is the executive director of Brazil's Climate Policy Institute, a think tank.

He said: "At times, we have an Environment Ministry that is deeply committed to these matters. But at critical moments, it has not been able rely on the support of federal government as it should." Lula's administration has reduced deforestation by half in the Amazon. This makes it easier to fine those who deforest and to deny them public credit. New policies encourage reforestation, sustainable farming practices and cattle tracking.

Critics say Lula’s government did not do enough to stop Congress from undermining environmental protections and blocking recognition of Indigenous land. The lawmakers have also attacked an agreement between the private sector and the Amazon to protect it from soy farming.

Lula's critics admit that he only has limited influence. The Senate passed a bill to revamp environmental permits after a government agency took too long to grant oil exploration licenses off the Amazon coast. Lula vetoed most of the bill but lawmakers promised to restore atleast part of it by this week.

Silva resigned over disagreements with cabinet members during Lula's previous mandate. Lula is quick to defend Silva and vice versa. In a recent interview at her Brasilia offices, Silva said that Lula hadn't changed but that the planet was warming up, which has increased the urgency for climate policy.

She said, "Reality has changed." "People who follow scientific criteria, common sense and ethics have been following this gradual change."

HIER TEMPERATURES, MORE GUNS

Earth's hottest ever year was 2024. Massive fires in Amazon rainforest wiped out more trees than bulldozers and chainsaws combined for the first.

Brazilians who want to protect the Amazon face more than just a warming climate and a sceptical Congress. Jair Schmitt said that the organized crime in the Amazon region has increased after years of limited funding, which left fewer federal employees to fight back.

He said that Ibama agents were more frequently involved in gunfights with gangs. This suggests there are more guns in the area than ever before.

He said that "Rifles were not so easy to find in the past."

Reports have revealed that illegal deforesters are also infiltrating Amazon supply chains, touting their sustainability. This includes biofuels and carbon credits.

Marcio Astirni, head of Climate Observatory and an advocacy group, said that Brazil must strengthen its political will to overcome these challenges. He added that "we have all the tools we need to succeed." (Reporting and editing by Brad Haynes, David Gregorio, and Manuela Andreoni)

(source: Reuters)