Latest News

Shell, Pals of the Earth each state European climate ruling backs their view in Dutch case

Shell told a Dutch court on Friday that a European climate judgment against the Swiss federal government supported their appeal versus a 2021 Dutch climate judgment since it validated that states and not courts ought to set rules on emissions decreases.

Friends of the Earth Netherlands, however - which brought the initial Shell case - said the precise reverse during the fourth and final day of hearings in Shell's appeal versus the 2021 Dutch judgment, in which a lower Dutch court bought Shell to minimize its planet-warming carbon emissions by 45% by 2030 from 2019 levels.

That order - a landmark ruling which stunned the energy sector - associated not just to Shell's own emissions however likewise to those triggered by the purchasers and users of its products worldwide.

During the hearings on Friday, Shell lawyer Daan Lunsingh Scheurleer said today's European Court of Human Rights ruling in the Swiss case altered absolutely nothing in the Dutch one.

However he said that in Shell's view, the ECHR choice that the Swiss federal government had violated the human rights of senior ladies by refraining from doing enough to fight environment change verified Shell's. point that emissions were a concern of state responsibility.

It does support Shell on the point that issuing a demand. for emissions reductions for companies is not up to courts but. ought to be the domain of states, Lunsingh Scheurleer told judges.

Friends of the Earth Netherlands responded that in fact the. European judgment supported their side.

The European Court of Human Rights verifies that environment. change is a human rights concern, attorney Roger Cox stated, including. that courts have a role to ensure business regard human. rights.

A spokesperson for Friends of the Earth Netherlands stated. that a ruling in the Dutch case is scheduled for November 12,. 2024.

(source: Reuters)