Latest News

Mamdani's reaction to the NYC comptroller's decision to drop BlackRock is a test for Mamdani

Brad Lander, New York City Comptroller, is urging pension fund officials in the city to rebid $42.3 billion to BlackRock due to climate concerns. This is the first major step taken by a Democrat against pressure from Republican allies who support the fossil fuel industry.

Lander's tenure in office ends Dec. 31. But his recommendation announced on Wednesday could put Mayor elect Zohran Mamdani under pressure when he assumes office in five weeks. BlackRock has indicated that it will try to retain the business. Mamdani’s appointees are in key positions and will have some influence over the pension boards, which decide where to invest retirement money for 800,000.

Lander, in a memo he sent to other trustees of pension funds on Nov. 25, urged them to reevaluate their contracts with New York's BlackRock. BlackRock is the largest asset manager in the world and also the largest manager of retirement assets for the city.

Lander pointed to what he described as "BlackRock’s restrictive approach to engaging" with approximately 2,800 U.S. firms in which the company owns more than 5 percent of shares.

'Abdication of Financial Duty'

BlackRock, under pressure from the Trump Administration in February, said that it would not try to control businesses through its discussions with executives. This was contrary to Lander's and other investors who were environmentally conscious, as they wanted to pressure executives to disclose emissions.

Lander stated in an interview that the change is "an abdication from financial duty" and makes them incapable of meeting our expectations regarding responsible investing.

The pension boards, which traditionally follow the lead of the comptroller’s office, must still approve his recommendation. Mamdani's representatives did not answer any questions. Mark Levine, Lander's successor, was represented by a representative who said that he would review the recommendations.

Lander, who was a rival of Mamdani's during the mayoral race, but became an ally, recommended to the pension plans that BlackRock continue managing non-U.S. index mandates, and other products.

Lander recommended that the three systems continue to use State Street for managing $8 billion of equity index assets and drop their deals with Fidelity Investments or PanAgora. He said they also did not push companies enough on environmental issues like decarbonization.

Armando Senra is the Head of Americas Institutional Business at BlackRock. In a letter sent to Lander by a BlackRock spokesperson, Senra said that Lander's claim that BlackRock had abdicated their financial responsibility and placed pensions in danger due to climate change was "another instance of the politization of public pension funds which undermines retirement security for hardworking New Yorkers."

Senra stated that if the pension officials accept Lander's recommendations, "we are looking forward to demonstrating our breadth and depth and the tremendous value" we provide to the city and public servants.

Other fund managers didn't immediately comment.

WASHINGTON PRESSURE

A number of Republicans, some from fossil-fuel-producing states, have withdrawn money from BlackRock and other money managers, accusing them of basing investment decisions on social or environmental issues. New York City funds are the first major asset owners with a liberal or Democratic lean to do so.

Lander confirmed earlier reports that he was "seriously" considering a run for Congress in the next election year. He said, however, that his recommendation about BlackRock had "nothing to do" his future plans. Lander noted that 46 out of 49 fund managers in the city had decarbonization plans that met his expectations.

Richard Brooks, director of the climate finance program for environmental advocacy group Stand.earth via email on Wednesday, praised Lander’s plan to drop BlackRock. Brooks stated that it was important for the pension trustees to take action, including those appointed by the mayor.

(source: Reuters)