Latest News

US carbon pipeline business vows no oil healing, but Bakken drillers want it

Top Carbon Solutions, which is attempting to develop the biggest carbon dioxide capture pipeline in the United States to transfer and bury greenhouse gases, has repeatedly vowed its task will not be utilized by drillers to boost output from oil fields.

However Top has a different message for potential customers, including North Dakota's oil sector, according to a evaluation of state regulatory filings and recordings of public appearances by company executives: if you wish to use our project for boosted oil recovery (EOR), where gas is pumped into oil fields to increase production, just write a check.

The dual messages show Top's efforts to court broad support for its $5.5 billion project, which might record as much as 18 million metric tons of CO2 yearly from 57 Midwest ethanol plants and store it underground at a website in North Dakota.

Whether Top is successful at its goal to begin in 2025 and begin operations in 2026 is a major test for carbon capture and storage, a crucial tool in the fight against environment change but which faces obstacles like unproven scalability and public apprehension.

The ethanol industry wants Top to sequester its carbon to drive down its carbon intensity and draw financially rewarding tax credits from state and federal clean fuel programs.

The oil market wants to utilize the pipeline for EOR, showing a belief among drillers in North Dakota's Bakken that oil recovery is required to reverse the once-booming region's. flagging output. North Dakota oil gamers introduced the group. Good friends of Ag and Energy in December to promote carbon pipelines. like Top's, consisting of through countless dollars of radio. ads.

With the Summit project, the capacity exists, the. size of the reward in the Bakken is considerable, and eventually,. I see an incredible long-term chance, North Dakota. Petroleum Council (NDPC) president Ron Ness informed .

Summit has actually long preserved, in both sworn testimony to state. pipeline regulators and on its site, that it does not plan. to utilize its task for EOR.

The Summit Carbon Solutions task will not be used for. boosted oil healing, the website reads. Top does not. mean to ship CO2 for usage in EOR, the company informed the Iowa. Utilities Board (IUB) last August.

Ecological groups typically oppose EOR because of its. potential to extend the life of the nonrenewable fuel sources industry.

More recently, Summit officials have actually indicated that. utilizing the pipeline to ship carbon for increasing oil production is. a future probability.

Today, we don't have any shippers who wish to ship CO2 for. EOR. When that modifications, we will likely move it for that. function, said Wade Boeshans, Top's executive vice president,. at a December 20 occasion held by Buddies of Ag and Energy in. Bismarck, North Dakota.

Top attorney Bret Dublinske told the IUB in a January 19. submitting that the business does not eventually control whether. future customers would utilize the pipeline for EOR.

And Bruce Rastetter, chairman of Summit's parent company. Summit Agricultural Group, likewise stated on a North Dakota radio. show on February 7 that the business is open to EOR.

Summit CEO Lee Blank stated the company's messaging on EOR is. constant.

The front-end goal of this company is the ethanol market. and the sequestration of carbon, and it will be that until the. market informs us to do anything different, he stated.

The business is likewise contractually obliged to sequester all. carbon it captures at ethanol plants who have actually signed on with the. company, Blank stated.

OIL INDUSTRY ALLIES

North Dakota's oil production peaked in late 2019 after a. nearly decade-long drilling boom that made it one of the. country's top crude providers, and it has yet to recuperate,. according to data from the Energy Details Administration.

The state will require as much as 10 times more CO2 than it. can capture from stationary sources to complimentary billions of barrels. of oil caught in Bakken fields, stated John Harju, vice president. for strategic collaborations at the University of North Dakota's. Energy and Environmental Research Center.

Importing CO2 through pipeline is something that I think at the. end of the day is going to be required, Harju said.

Top has dealt with problems in protecting state permits,. including in North Dakota, and land easements from some. landowners along its path over security, land rights, and. ecological concerns.

In a quote to construct public assistance, Pals of Ag and Energy. advertised on 6 North Dakota radio stations in between early. December and February, according to records preserved by the. Federal Communications Commission. Invoices show that in. December, the group paid a total of $16,366 for 487 ads across. the 6 stations. Invoices for other months were not readily available.

The group's chair, Kathleen Neset, is a North Dakota oil. sector expert and member of the North Dakota Petroleum. Council board. Neset did not respond to an interview request.

Its parent company, Primus Incorporated, counts. influential figures in the state oil market as its board. donors and members, according to the group's public filings.

Summit's present focus on sequestration is in part due to. the 45Q tax credit program, expanded by the Inflation Reduction. Act, which provides $85 per lots of sequestered carbon and just $50. per heap for EOR.

A shift in that policy could modify the company's priorities. around EOR, executives and oil industry players said.

(source: Reuters)