Latest News

Spanish wildfire victims were left to their own devices because of patchy warnings and outdated plans

Twelve people died on July 9 trying to escape wildfires in the southern Spanish village of Bedar. Regional officials claimed that some had refused to stay at their homes. Five residents and survivors said they never received any advice, and two others, who did, claimed that warnings were given via WhatsApp groups, church bells, and home visits by local officials. Bob Layton, retired British technical manager, claimed he did not receive any warnings or advice about the fire. He drove away just a few minutes before the wildfire engulfed the home he was in, Paraje el Curato. This is a hamlet located about 2,5 km (1,55 miles) south of Bedar, where the majority of those who died were trying to flee.

Burns claimed the life of a British woman aged 93.

Layton stated, "If I'd been told to stay inside my house we would all have died - the place was completely destroyed."

"I knew which track to use to escape, but others tried to take a slightly different track or a slightly longer route, and did not survive. The fire turned into an inferno."

In Paraje el Curato, some homes were destroyed and others survived.

After the main road was closed, eight people, including Layton's neighbours, were killed trying to leave Paraje el Curato along the same route. Four other people died in another convoy.

The fire did not reach the hamlet for 3.5 hours, at which point the main road was already blocked.

Antonio Sanz, the head of emergency services in Andalusia said that the region decided against using an "emergency alert system" which sends mobile phone alerts for the fire, because it could not be tailored to specific community, where some need to evacuate while others stay at home. Last week, other regions like Madrid, Aragon and Castile La Mancha used the system to warn of wildfires.

Andalusia's government issued a statement in July?11 stating that the mayor of Bedar and other officials went door-to-door in the area giving advice and also telling victims in Paraje el Curato shelter in place.

Sophie Vandebroek's brother Stanislas was one of those killed. She said that he did not receive an evacuation warning which would have allowed them to do so safely.

She said, "If there had been communication via the emergency alert system, when the fire broke, before my brother even saw the fire, Stanislas, and his seven neighbours would still be alive," she said.

She said that she and her family spoke with the victims' families and mayor. Some relatives discussed with their family members whether or not they should leave.

She added, "It seems that no one who died received an official communication before the time it was too late."

Bedar Town Hall did not respond to email or phone requests for comment. The mayor of Bedar, Angel Collado declined an interview request.

The spokesperson for the local police confirmed that all relevant facts regarding the fire are being investigated, but did not make any further statements as the case has been sealed. The spokesperson for Andalusia’s Supreme Court stated that the judge is basing his investigation on the cause.

FIRE SPREADING FASTER

Wildfires are spreading faster and more often in Europe. Experts say that it is important to communicate evacuation plans as well as safety details long before the fire starts.

The public should be informed in advance about the dangers in the area and the evacuation routes. They must also know the basic measures for self-protection. It is important to map out the scattered houses, plan evacuations, and carry out drills. This was explained by Fernando Medina a professor of geography from the University of Las Palmas of Grand?Canaria.

Almeria is the Andalusian region that includes Bedar. Only 42 of 103 municipalities had emergency plans, which included wildfires. According to the Andalusia Government, only nine municipalities had updated their fire plans every four years in areas of risk.

A spokesperson for the Andalusian Government said that Bedar's Emergency Plan was approved last in 2019. It is currently being updated. Wildfires are a risk to the?municipality.

When asked about the lack plans, the spokesperson stated that the Andalusian Government provides advice and assistance but it is the responsibility of the municipalities to update their plans.

Bedar's Town Hall did not respond to several requests for comments on its evacuation plans or if it had conducted wildfire drills.

A statement online states that the Almeria government met with 49 municipalities in February at Los Gallardos (near Bedar) to discuss how to streamline updating emergency plans. Bedar's town hall did not respond to an inquiry asking if it participated in the February meeting.

Some people who lived closer to Bedar, than the hamlet, received warnings. Waheed Mumtaz said that police told him to evacuate at 10:30 pm.

Juan Pedro, who works at Bedar’s Miramar, said that the church bells started ringing "soon" after the fire began. He said he received a message from the townhall via WhatsApp telling him to evacuate.

He said that as soon as the smoke was visible, the bells rang, and the word spread, everyone in the village knew to leave.

Not everyone was part of that WhatsApp group. Pedro Tierney, 31 saw the fire from a distance and ran home to save his grandmother and aunt in a car.

He said that it was his "gut feeling" that he had to leave, and that he did not receive any alerts to evacuate.

David Alexander, professor emeritus of emergency planning at University College London, explained that wildfires can be blown in a different direction by the wind. This makes it difficult for authorities to communicate instructions.

He said that the haphazard nature of the messages during this fire indicates poor planning. He said they should have used an alert, even if it was not possible to send specific instructions, to warn people of the fire.

Layton called on authorities to work with residents to develop a plan to alert people to imminent dangers in the future.

He said: "I don't want to blame anyone - everything happened so fast - but it was despicable for them to try and assign blame." Reporting by Nina Lopez; Additional reporting by Emma Pinedo and Alexandra Hudson; Editing by Alexandra Hudson

(source: Reuters)