Latest News

Australian accused of mushroom killings had no motive to kill, court heard

Australian accused of mushroom killings had no motive to kill, court heard

The lawyer for an Australian woman accused in the murder of three elderly relatives by her estranged spouse using toxic mushrooms in a meal had told the court Tuesday that the victim's motive was not to kill the victims.

Erin Patterson has been charged with the murders and attempted murders of Gail Patterson's mother, Donald Patterson's father, Gail's sister Heather Wilkinson as well as Heather's husband Ian Wilkinson in July 2023.

The prosecution accuses the woman of scouring for poisonous death caps mushrooms, drying them, and then knowingly serving these mushrooms in portions of Beef Wellington, at her home, in Leongatha. This town has a population of 6,000, about 135 kilometers (84 miles), from Melbourne.

Patterson denies all charges that carry a sentence of life imprisonment. Her defence called the deaths "a terrible accident" earlier.

Colin Mandy, Patterson's lawyer, said on Tuesday that the prosecution's evidence that the accused and her estranged spouse Simon Patterson's relationship soured over a disagreement about child support was illogical.

He told the court that "whatever we call these spats, disagreements, and frustrations," it does not provide a motive for murdering someone's parents.

He said that the accused actually had a good working relationship with the Pattersons, and had even loaned hundreds of thousands to Simon Patterson's sisters in order to purchase property.

On Tuesday, Nanette Rogers concluded the closing argument of the prosecution by accusing Patterson a trail of calculated deceptions before and after lunch.

Rogers said that Erin Patterson had told so many lies, it was difficult to keep track of them.

She's told lies after lies because she knew that the truth would expose her.

After the closing statement of the defence, Justice Christopher Beale, the presiding judge will instruct the jury on how to proceed before the jury retires to deliberate a verdict.

The trial that has gripped Australia for eight weeks and is expected to end later this month.

(source: Reuters)